Volume X · Orchestral works

§ Maurice Ravel — 1907-1908, M. 54

Rapsodie espagnole.

Suite for orchestra — premiered Théâtre du Châtelet, 15 March 1908

2023 revised edition under the editorial direction of François Dru. Suite in four movements for large orchestra, premiered at the Théâtre du Châtelet by the Orchestre Colonne on 15 March 1908. Reading committee: Fabien Gabel, Ludovic Morlot, Alain Pâris, Benjamin Attahir. World premiere of the revised edition by the Detroit Symphony Orchestra under the direction of Fabien Gabel, Symphony Hall, 9 November 2023.

01 // Genesis

Orchestral manuscript

1907-08 Feria dated "January-February 1908" in Ravel's own hand. Manuscript held at the Carlton Lake Collection, Harry Ransom Center, Austin (Texas).

02 // Premiere

Colonne Sunday concert

15.III.1908 Théâtre du Châtelet, Paris. Orchestre Colonne under the baton of Édouard Colonne. The Malagueña was encored to gallery bravos.

03 // Edition

Editorial direction François Dru

Rev. 2023 World premiere of the revised edition by the Detroit Symphony Orchestra / Fabien Gabel, 9 November 2023. Contact: sales@21-music.be.

Editorial direction & reading committee

Editorial direction

Revised edition under the editorial direction of François Dru.

Reading committee

Fabien Gabel

Conductor

Fabien Gabel

Ludovic Morlot

Conductor

Ludovic Morlot

Alain Pâris

Conductor & music writer

Alain Pâris

Benjamin Attahir

Composer

Benjamin Attahir

Editorial direction

François Dru — 2023 revised edition, Ravel Edition Volume X.

Editorial note

March 1908 — a "Rapsodie" without an h

On the meteoric genesis of the winter of 1907-1908, the Châtelet scandal, the first Durand engraving of July 1908 and the enigmas of figure 19 in Feria.

By François Dru — November 2023

March 1908. Although the Hispanic vein had continued, more than thirty years after the premiere of Carmen, to delight Parisian and Monegasque audiences1, the Spain dreamt by the young Ravel was quite unlike the fashionable espagnolades of the day. To the Iberian thematic material, to Baudelaire's "In the perfumed country the sun caresses"2, which had accompanied the musician since 1895, and to the nocturnal impressions of his pianistic Habanera drawn from the Sites auriculaires, he offered the Sunday Parisian audience at the Théâtre du Châtelet, on 15 March 1908, his first large orchestral work — one that would become a cardinal reference.

Manuscript of the Habanera
Manuscript of the Habanera. The movement, originally drawn from the Sites auriculaires for two pianos (1895), would be incorporated as the second movement of the Rapsodie espagnole upon its orchestration in 1907-1908.
Yale University Library, GEN MSS 601

Roland-Manuel, in 1928, noted:

In the Rapsodie espagnole there resounds for the first time that nervous, feline orchestra whose transparency and clarity are exemplary, whose joyful and dry sonority is like the very mark of Ravel. Roland-Manuel, 19283

Setting aside the Ouverture Shéhérazade of 1899, "poorly received"4 by the audience, the bitter failure, in February 1907, of the orchestration of Une Barque sur l'océan56, and leaving aside the sonorous setting of the voice-and-orchestra cycle Shéhérazade of 1903, this Suite in four movements for a very large orchestra was the first fully deployed manifesto of Ravel's orchestral mastery.

Of its genesis, very few elements remain: Arbie Orenstein7 nonetheless specifies the date of October 19078, Ravel's "Spanish year", during which he was concurrently composing what would become L'Heure espagnole. That year does indeed appear as an epigraph on the Durand edition of the piano four-hand reduction (D. & F. 6999, first published in March 19089).

As for the orchestration, thanks to the autograph dating that appears on the final bar of the orchestral manuscript10 of Feria: "January-February 1908"11, we fully grasp the arduous character of the end of the winter of 1907-08, spent completing the orchestrated version of this Rapsodie without an h, expressed for instance in the words of the letter of 3 March 1908 sent to his colleague — and nonetheless friend — Ralph Vaughan Williams:

I've had a frightful amount of work these last few days. My Rapsodie espagnole has to be given at Colonne on 15 March. Only the 4th part was orchestrated! Ravel to Vaughan Williams, 3 March 190812

While the context of the composition of these Spanish scenes remains to be documented, the premiere was extensively commented upon by the musical press. Both admirers and detractors devoted no small amount of space in their columns to the review of the young musician's new opus — a young musician who had by then moved from successive failures to scandal, into new polemical shots. From this querelle des anciens et des modernes, which commented on the boos of the stalls and the bravos of the gallery, and on the composer's friends who nevertheless succeeded in encoring the spirited Malagueña, was reported, during the rehearsals and the concert13, the discontent of the orchestra's musicians in the face of the difficulties of the score, the "excess of mutes"14 in the strings, or the mocked effect of "progressive muting" in the brass15.

Ravel himself noted, in a letter of 25 March 190816:

Like guinea fowl, the rehearsals, corrections, reductions, etc. grant me a brief respite. But I sense them returning, turbulent… it went well on Sunday, Colonne proved full of devotion and skill, and the audience full of warmth. The critics are more lukewarm, but that matters less. Ravel, 25 March 1908

We know that the first engraving of the Durand "Orchestral Score" (D. & F. 7128 — first printing of one hundred copies), together with the "Separate Parts" (D. & F. 7124), came off the presses of the Imprimerie Chaimbaud in July 1908, bearing the stamps of the engraver-artist Charles Douin.

In keeping with common practice — the publisher destroying whatever was not definitive — no trace remains of the initial, temporary material used for the work's premiere. Of this creation, under the baton of the venerable Édouard Colonne17, all that survives, directly on the manuscript, are strokes of blue or red pencil to aid performance, together with red-ink markings (from Colonne or from Durand's editorial manager?) intended to correct copying errors, recopyings, or modifications of the composer's indications — the recurrent case, seen in later Ravel manuscripts, of mutes for the solo strings while the string tutti plays without mutes…

Moreover, on this thirty-stave music paper, with Ravel's fine handwriting — rare in that it is in violet ink, of great graphic quality, which allows one to distinguish without hesitation, for example, all the subtleties of the string writing in its many divisions — one also sees the pencil indications made in preparation for engraving (counts of the number of staves per page, corrections, redistribution of the instruments of the "Batterie", etc.). On each fascicle that makes up the suite, on every opening page, as legal marking, appears the ink stamp of Durand & Fils18.

Annotated cadenza of the orchestral manuscript
Annotated cadenza of the orchestral manuscript. Blue and red pencil strokes for performance, together with red-ink markings — corrections by Édouard Colonne or by Durand's editorial manager for the preparation of the premiere of 15 March 1908.
Harry Ransom Center, Carlton Lake Collection, Box-Folder 300

The Parisian association orchestras, which did so much for Ravel's fame, hold in their libraries materials that were acquired in the 1920s. That of the Orchestre Lamoureux shows a first use in 1926, with similar dates for the Orchestre Colonne, which may indicate a new printing of the material in the 1920s19. Among the corrections entered by hand in the separate parts appear, among others, the missing bars for the tuba or the double basses, erroneous substitutions between the second clarinet and the bass clarinet, or the reallocation of the elements of the "Batterie" so as to limit the number of players required for this plethoric ensemble.

Unfortunately, no explanation in the form of corrections remains regarding the famous figure 19 of Feria: with the thorny question of the metric correspondence between the episodes — differing between the piano version and the orchestra — and the strange case of the ritornello motif missing from the orchestra yet clearly present in the preparatory version for piano.

Critical notes

  1. Espada by Jules Massenet was premiered in February 1908 at the Opéra de Monte-Carlo, while, also in February, La Habanera by Raoul Laparra was resounding at the Opéra-Comique in Paris (Salle Favart). At the stylistic opposite, in 1908, Debussy was completing Iberia, which was not performed before 1910. The pianistic Soirée dans Grenade, by the same composer, dates from 1903.
  2. Autograph epigraph on the manuscript of the Habanera for two pianos of 1895. Yale University Library, GEN MSS 601.
  3. Roland-Manuel, Maurice Ravel et son œuvre dramatique, Les Éditions musicales de la Librairie de France, Paris, 1928.
  4. Roland-Manuel, page 15, work cited.
  5. Premiered on 3 February 1907, Théâtre du Châtelet in Paris, by the Orchestre Colonne under the direction of G. Pierné. "…whose modern tendencies were somewhat severely received" (Revue française politique et littéraire, 10 February 1907, page 40). "The audience's reception of the new work was what could be expected: passionate applause from the artists and significant ill temper from this audience of amateurs whose boos so surely consecrate young glories…" — Émile Vuillermoz, La Nouvelle presse, 4 February 1907, front page.
  6. Once again with the Orchestre Colonne under the direction of G. Pierné. An orchestration that Ravel definitively banished from his catalogue after the premiere, and which made a strange return to the desks of the Orchestre Pasdeloup in February 1950, recorded by the LSO under the direction of G. Poulet in December 1953 (EMI, on CD by Dutton, digitally by BNF Collection), before being officially published by Eschig (ref. M.E. 8411) in 1983.
  7. Arbie Orenstein, Ravel — Man and Musician, Columbia University Press, New York, 1975.
  8. The manuscript of the two-piano reduction is part of the Collection Taverne and is inaccessible.
  9. Cf. Nigel Simeone, "Mother Goose and other golden eggs: Durand editions of Ravel as reflected in the firm's printing records", IAML Publications UK, 1998, Vol. 35, No. 2, pages 58-79.
  10. Carlton Lake Collection, Box-Folder 300, Harry Ransom Center, Austin, Texas.
  11. Original marking: "I II 1908".
  12. Maurice Ravel — Lettres, Écrits et Entretiens, presented and annotated by Arbie Orenstein, coll. Harmoniques, Flammarion, Paris, 1989. As with the orchestration of Pictures at an Exhibition, Ravel thus began with the ending and the weightiest movement.
  13. Louis Laloy, La Grande Revue, 25 March 1908.
  14. Pierre Lalo, Le Temps, 24 March 1908.
  15. "L'ouvreuse", Comœdia, 23 March 1908 — on the trumpets at the conclusion of the Habanera.
  16. Fragments of the letter reproduced, page 97, in the Catalogue of the auction sale of the "Archives Lucien Garban — Letters and manuscripts of Maurice Ravel" of 8 April 1992, Paris-Drouot Richelieu. Several copies of the catalogue are held at the BnF (VMB-6636 and VMB 6463).
  17. Édouard Colonne (1838-1910), founder in 1873 of the Association artistique des Concerts Colonne.
  18. Full stamp: "MATÉRIEL D'ORCHESTRE — Appartenant à Mrs A. Durand & Fils — Éditeurs-Propriétaires — 4, Place de la Madeleine, PARIS."
  19. Charles Münch owned a large-format Orchestral Score bearing the marking "Imp. A. Mounot", thus later than the first printing. Leonard Bernstein conducted from an Orchestral Score printed in 1938 by the "IFMRP".

World premiere of the revised edition

Detroit, Symphony Hall

The world premiere of the new edition was given in the United States by the Detroit Symphony Orchestra under the direction of Fabien Gabel, member of the reading committee.

9
November
2023
World premiere
Symphony Hall
Detroit — Michigan, USA
Detroit Symphony Orchestra
Conductor: Fabien Gabel

// Share this edition

Order

Order the score & orchestral material

sales@21-music.be